Close Menu
Asberth News Network
    Facebook Instagram
    • Home
    • Privacy Policy
    • Terms of use
    • Download App
    Facebook Instagram
    Asberth News Network
    • Home
    • Latest News
    • Breaking News
    • Local News
    • Regional/International News
    • Sports
    • Opinion
    • Back to School
    Asberth News Network
    Home»Main Story»Social Protest is Essential to Democracy (Pt.2)
    Main Story

    Social Protest is Essential to Democracy (Pt.2)

    September 10, 2021No Comments5 Mins Read
    Facebook Twitter LinkedIn Email Telegram WhatsApp
    Dr. Godwin Friday
    Share
    Facebook Twitter LinkedIn Pinterest Email


    (Excerpts of Dr. Friday’s Press Statement)


    Social protests and disruptions
    In its report, the IACHR: “… acknowledges that in different circumstances protests cause
    disruption and affect the normal course of other activities, but this fact does not make these
    forms of expression per se illegitimate. It is based on the fact that one of the functions of protest
    is to channel and amplify the demands, aspirations, and grievances of different segments of the
    population…”.


    In para 41 , the OAS report says: “It is inherent to the functioning of a democratic society that
    the State must continuously weigh competing or conflicting legitimate rights and interests
    against each other. And this weighing, under the requirement of necessity…means that at times
    the exercise of freedom of assembly can alter daily… routines, especially in large urban centers,
    and even create nuisances or affect the exercise of other rights that should be protected and
    guaranteed by the State, such as freedom of movement. Nevertheless, “such disruptions are part
    of the mechanics of a pluralistic society in which diverse and sometimes conflicting interests
    coexist and find the forums and channels in which to express themselves.””


    “Restrictions must also be strictly “proportionate” to the legitimate aim for which they are
    intended, and closely tailored to the achievement of that aim, interfering as little as possible with
    the lawful exercise of that right. To determine the strict proportionality of the restrictive measure,
    it must be determined whether the sacrifice of freedom of expression it entails is exaggerated or
    excessive in relation to the advantages obtained through such measure.”


    The Right to Participate in Protest without Prior Authorization
    The IACHR has considered that the exercise of freedom of assembly through social protest
    should not be subject to government authorization or excessive requirements that make it
    difficult to carry out. Legal requirements underlying the prohibition or limitation of a meeting or
    demonstration, such as the requirement of prior permission, are not compatible with freedom of
    assembly or the exercise of freedom of expression in the inter-American system.
    Prior notice, generally justified by States on the basis of the need to provide greater protection to
    a demonstration, cannot function as a covert authorization mechanism. … the requirement of
    prior notification must not be confused with the requirement of prior authorization granted in a
    discretional manner, which must not be established in the law or practice of the administrative
    authorities, even when it comes to public spaces..


    The United Nations Special Rapporteur on the rights to freedom of peaceful assembly and
    association has been emphatic in stating that he “believes that the exercise of fundamental
    freedoms should not be subject to previous authorization by the authorities (…), but at the most
    to a prior notification procedure, whose rationale is to allow State authorities to facilitate the
    exercise of the right to freedom of peaceful assembly and to take measures to protect public

    safety and order and the rights and freedoms of others.” At the same time, the existence of
    mechanisms requiring demonstrators to notify the authorities in advance of the place, date, and
    time of the protest is only compatible with Article 13 of the ACHR when States require it in
    order to be able to take measures to protect demonstrators and thus facilitate social protest.
    Similarly, when notification procedures are very bureaucratic or intervene unnecessarily or
    disproportionately in determining the place, time, and manner of a protest, have a chilling effect
    on the exercise of this right. With regard to the requirement of prior notice to hold a protest, the
    United Nations Special Rapporteur on the rights to freedom of peaceful assembly and
    association, has said that “such a notification should be subject to a proportionality assessment,
    not unduly bureaucratic.” In particular, prior notification should be requested only for large
    gatherings or events that could cause transit disruptions in order to facilitate their conduct and
    protect demonstrators.


    In addition, the organizers’ failure to give prior notification to the authorities should not lead to
    the break-up of the gathering or to the imposition of criminal or administrative penalties such as
    fines or deprivation of liberty against the organizers, leaders, or their associations. Under this
    same interpretation, the European Court of Human Rights held that the dissolution of a peaceful
    demonstration for failure to comply with the prior notification requirement constitutes a
    disproportionate restriction on the freedom of peaceful assembly.
    Spontaneous demonstrations are also protected. Spontaneous gatherings should be exempt from
    the notification requirement and law enforcement should, to the extent possible, protect and
    facilitate spontaneous gatherings as they would any other such event.99 This Commission
    recommends that States take account of the fact that there are events in which it is not possible to
    identify the organizers and that, although announced in advance, take place in a highly
    improvised and spontaneous manner. The impossibility of identifying the organizers of a
    demonstration cannot justify the prohibition, dissolution, or repression of a demonstration. In
    addition, a spontaneous change in a march’s route does not negate the obligation to facilitate
    protest and protect demonstrators and third parties present.


    The notification procedure, moreover, cannot be regarded as a binding commitment by the
    organizers to the time, place, and manner of a protest. Nor is it reasonable for the notification
    procedure to serve as a basis for the imposition of penalties for acts committed by third parties
    against persons or organizations that have assumed the functions of dissemination, organization,
    or dialogue with the State with respect to a protest.


    The duty to not criminalize leaders and participants in demonstrations and protests. This is very
    helpful guidance given what is happening here in SVG, where people homes have been raided
    and two persons have been charged with offences stemming from their perceived roles in the
    recent protests in Kingstown.

    Share. Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn Tumblr Email

    Related Posts

    SVGAT 2025 Scholarship Program Now Open – Empowering Vincentian Youth in Toronto

    June 24, 2025

    SVGTU Congratulates Students on CPEA Success

    June 24, 2025

    Four Young Athletes to Represent SVG at NACAC U13 & U15 Championships in Nicaragua

    June 24, 2025

    Big Bad Ragga and Soca Monarch finalst announced : Hance John and Fireman Hooper Set to Defend Their Crowns

    June 24, 2025
    Add A Comment

    Comments are closed.

    • Home
    • Latest News
    • Breaking News
    • Local News
    • Regional/International News
    • Sports
    • Opinion
    • Back to School
    Our Socials
    • Facebook
    • Instagram
    ANN

    Asbert News Network is the premier destination for local, regional and international news in St. Vincent and the Grenadines. It’s tomorrow’s news today.

    © 2025 Asbert News Network
    • Home
    • Privacy Policy
    • Terms of use
    • Download App

    Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.